Court Case Record EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV UID(8b82)

EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. Court Case Record

Court Case Number: E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV

Case Number	E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV
Case Title	EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL.
Case Type	Appellate Case
State	Tennessee, TN
County	Knox County
Court	Knox County Chancery Court
Court Address	Administrative Office of the Courts 511 Union Street, Suite 600 Nashville, TN 37219
Phone	(615) 741-2687 \| (800) 448-7970
Field Date	05/07/2014
Close Date	02/03/2014

Parties

Counsel	Name	Type
Smith, Thomas Kenan	Harris, Emma	Appellant/Plaintiff
Smith, Thomas Kenan	Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC	Appellant/Plaintiff
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Aldmon, Amanda B.	Appellee/Defendant
Seymour Jr., Arthur Gloster	Whaley, Robert A.	Appellant/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Bommelje, Sarah M.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Christian, Bryan J.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Combs, Sarah J.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cooper, Julia B.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cragle, Donna L.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Durfee, Alan Christopher	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Eimers, Carol E.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Hammer, Alvin Butler	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Hammond, Marilyn B.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Helton, Timothy S.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Henegar, Ruth	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Hill, Nelda A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Hornbaker, William S.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Horton, Bettye Kolter	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Howell, Jimmy L.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Keith, Beverly Humphreys	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Klimek, John B.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Leidig, Mary Beth	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Lind, Carol L.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Muffler, Mary K.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Muffler, Steven	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Prosser, Joan	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Riggs, Carolyn Ogg	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Thomas, Joyce Anna	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Weigenstein, Timothy E.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Zinavage, Carol	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Hornbaker, Margaret	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Thomas, Charles	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Aldmon, Thomas G.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Bales, Cheryl Ann	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Bales, Stephen R.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Beal, Alan C.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Beal, Karen	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Bell, Herbert A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Bell, Wanda H.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Brennan, James A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Brennan, Mary K.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cavanaugh, Eugene F.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cavanaugh, Connie	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Chady, Markus E.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Chady, Erin S.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cloninger, Kenneth A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Cloninger, Kathy O.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Currie, Stuart	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Currie, Donna	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Dickinson, Paul A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Dickinson, Nancy S.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Galyon Jr., Paul E.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Galyon, Mary Jane	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Horner, Jason W.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Horner, Christine N.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Huffman, James H.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Huffman, Judy	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Lopez, Synda M.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Lopez, Pedro P.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	McCullock, Kim L.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	McCullock, Shannon P.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Obenschain, Lesli A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Obenschain, Charles G.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Pena, Jose C.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Pena, Kristen E.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Ridner, Corey A.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Ridner, Te P.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Trivette, Judith Needham	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Trivette, Jerry	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Williamson, Anona D.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Williamson, Stan M.	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	Andrew, Barbara	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	McDonald, Lowell	Appellee/Defendant
Rhea, Dan Douglas	McDonald, Sammye	Appellee/Defendant

Buy Full Report

Case Overview
Style	Trial Court	Trial Court Judge	Trial Court No.	Inter. Case No.
EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL.	Knox County Chancery Court	Moyers, Michael W.	1808432

Case Milestones
Description	Date
Appeal Filed	02/03/2014
Record Filed	05/07/2014
Appellant(s) Briefing Complete	07/07/2014
Appellee(s) Briefing Complete	09/05/2014
Oral Argument/Submission	10/29/2014
Panel	03/30/2015
Decision Date	Opinion
Decision Type	Affirmed in Part, Reversed in Part
Disposition	07/13/2015
Appeal to S. Ct. Date
Closed Date

Parties
Names	Role	Counsel
Harris, Emma	Appellant/Plaintiff	Smith, Thomas Kenan
Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC	Appellant/Plaintiff	Smith, Thomas Kenan
Aldmon, Amanda B.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Whaley, Robert A.	Appellant/Defendant	Seymour Jr., Arthur Gloster
Bommelje, Sarah M.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Christian, Bryan J.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Combs, Sarah J.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Cooper, Julia B.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Cragle, Donna L.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Durfee, Alan Christopher	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Eimers, Carol E.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Hammer, Alvin Butler	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Hammond, Marilyn B.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Helton, Timothy S.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Henegar, Ruth	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Hill, Nelda A.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Hornbaker, William S.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Horton, Bettye Kolter	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Howell, Jimmy L.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Keith, Beverly Humphreys	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Klimek, John B.	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas
Leidig, Mary Beth	Appellee/Defendant	Rhea, Dan Douglas

Case History
Date	Event	Filer	PDF
07/13/2015	Appellate Record-Sent to Local Archive	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)	PDF PDF
07/13/2015	Mandate-Issued	Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
04/21/2015	Order-Petition to Rehear Granted	Rhea, Dan Douglas (Attorney)
04/08/2015	Response-to Petition to Rehear	Dan Douglas Rhea
04/07/2015	Petition-to Rehear	Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
03/30/2015	Opinion-Filed	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
03/30/2015	Appellate Record-Checked In from Court	Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
10/24/2014	Appellate Record-Checked Out to Court	Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
10/03/2014	Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument	Taylor Daniel Forrester
09/30/2014	Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument	Arthur Gloster Seymour, Jr.
09/29/2014	Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument	Taylor Daniel Forrester
09/26/2014	Docket Activity-Docketed (Oral Argument)	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
09/18/2014	Brief-Reply Brief Filed	Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
09/18/2014	Appellate Record-Checked In	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
09/10/2014	Appellate Record-Checked Out	Thomas Kenan Smith
09/05/2014	Case Status-APPELLEE BRIEFING COMPLETE	Whaley, Robert A. (Appellee/Defendant)
09/05/2014	Brief-Appellee's Brief Filed	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
09/05/2014	Appellate Record-Checked In	Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Tom and Amanda (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen and Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan and Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert and Wanda (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James and Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene and Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus and Erin (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth and Kathy (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart and Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul and Nancy (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan (Appellee/Defendant); Elmers, Carol (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Paul and Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason and Christie (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James and Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth (Appellee/Defendant); Lind, Carol (Appellee/Defendant); Lopez, Synda and Pedro (Appellee/Defendant); McCullock, Kim and Shannon (Appellee/Defendant); McDonald, Lowell and Sammye (Appellee/Defendant); Muffler, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Muffler, Steven (Appellee/Defendant); Obenschain, Lesli and Charles (Appellee/Defendant); Pena, Jose and Kirsten (Appellee/Defendant); Prosser, Joan (Appellee/Defendant); Ridner, Corey and Te P. (Appe
08/28/2014	Appellate Record-Supplemental Filed	Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
08/25/2014	Appellate Record-Supplemental Received	Whaley, Robert (Appellee/Defendant)
08/18/2014	Order-Supplement to Record	Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
08/06/2014	Order Related to Extension-Granted

Record Information
Volume Type	Volumes	Record Type
Technical Record	1	Supplemental
Exhibits	1	Supplemental
Technical Record	1	Supplemental
Exhibits	4	Supplemental
Technical Record	7	Original
Transcript of Evidence	3	Original
Exhibits	42	Original

Buy Full Report

Court Case Record EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV UID(8b82)

EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. Court Case Record

Court Case Number: E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV

Parties

Last Viewed