seal

Court Case Record BERNARD D. BRAHM & another vs. HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION OF PROVINCETOWN 2012-P-0040 UID(e991)


BERNARD D. BRAHM & another vs. HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION OF PROVINCETOWN Court Case Record

Court Case Number: 2012-P-0040


 
Case Number2012-P-0040
Case TitleBERNARD D. BRAHM & another vs. HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION OF PROVINCETOWN
Case TypeCivil
StateMassachusetts, MA
CountyBarnstable
CourtBarnstable Superior Court
Court Address
Phone
Field Date06/15/2009
Close Date10/31/2012

Parties

CounselNameType
Edward T. Patten, EsquireBernard D. BrahmPlaintiff/Appellee
Edward T. Patten, EsquireScott A. ShamenekPlaintiff/Appellee
Megan B. Bayer, Esquire Ilana M. Quirk, EsquireHistoric Distric ProvincetownDefendant/Appellant
DOCKET ENTRIES
Entry Date Paper Entry Text
01/12/2012 #1 Entered.
01/12/2012 #2 Notice of entry sent.
01/20/2012 #3 Docketing Statement received from Historic District Commission of Provincetown.
02/08/2012 #4 MOTION to extend brief & appendix due date, filed by Historic District Commission of Provincetown.
02/09/2012 #5 RE#3: Extension to 03/23/2012 granted for filing of brief of Historic District Commission of Provincetown, Defendant/Appellant. Notice to counsel.
02/10/2012 #6 Revised docket entries (certified; two copies) re: Stay of judgment received from Barnstable Superior Court.
02/27/2012 #7 MOTION to stay judgment during the appeal, filed by Historic District Commission of Provincetown.
02/28/2012 #8 Copy of trial court opposition received by fax received from Kopelman And Paige PC.
02/28/2012 #9 RE#5: Counsel for appellees has graciously agreed that no action will be taken to file for the certificate pending review of the within. *Notice.
03/06/2012 #10 RE#5: REVISED ACTION: Denied. (Agnes, J.) *Notice/Attest.
03/23/2012 #11 SERVICE of brief & appendix for Defendant/Appellant Historic District Commission of Provincetown.
04/19/2012 #12 MOTION to extend brief due date of Bernard D. Brahm, Scott A. Shamenek.
04/19/2012 #13 RE#8: Extension to 05/23/2012 granted for filing of brief of Bernard D. Brahm, & Scott A. Shamenek, Plaintiffs/Appellees. Notice to counsel.
05/07/2012 SERVICE of brief for Plaintiffs/Appellees Bernard D. Brahm and Scott A. Shamenek.
07/11/2012 Notice sent seeking information on unavailability for oral argument in September 2012
07/12/2012 Letter of Edward T. Patten, Esquire unavailable for oral argument 9/6, 9/12, 9/14
07/26/2012 Notice of 09/07/2012, 9:30 AM argument at John Adams Courthouse, Courtroom 4 (a4) sent.
09/07/2012 Oral argument held. (Green, J., Fecteau, J., Milkey, J.).
10/02/2012 Decision: Rule 1:28 (Green, Fecteau, Milkey, JJ.). So much of the judgment of the Superior Court as orders the commission to issue a certificate is vacated and the matter is remanded to the Superior Court where an order is to enter requesting the commission to provide a supplemental statement explaining the rationale for its decision. In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed. *Notice.
10/22/2012 Letter requesting copy oral argument CD, with payment of $50.50 via EPAY, from Bernard D. Brahm.
10/31/2012 RESCRIPT to Trial Court.